Fifteen By Beverly Cleary

Beverly Cleary, bless her nonagenarian heart, is best known for her juvenile fiction about the Leave It To Beaver-type adventures of Henry Huggins, and Beezus (and especially) Ramona Quimby:   books that manage to realistically capture the high drama that is inherent in being an 8-to-12 year old child.

Fifteen By Beverly Cleary

Less well known are the YA Romances from early in her career: Fifteen (1956), The Luckiest Girl(1958), Jean and Johnny (1959) and Sister of the Bride (1963). In the early 1980s Dell reissued these four titles as trade paperbacks under the “Young Love” imprint with terrible cover art and jacket descriptions that have nothing to do with what actually happens in the book. In fact, Fifteen has been consistently in print for over 50 years (yay!) but subjected to a variety of dull and insipid updates to the cover art.

The Plot: It’s basically a few months in the ballet of social awkwardness that is adolescence, as 15 year old lower-middle class (plain) Jane Purdy deals with well-intentioned but TOTALLY EMBARASSING parents, catty cashmere-sweater wearing popular girls, various misunderstandings with the boy she has a crush on, and being a white suburbanite eating at a Chinese restaurant in 1956.

Jane meets Stan Crandall while she is babysitting bratty proto-Ramona Sandra Norton, who is holding Jane hostage by threatening to dump a bottle of ink on the carpet unless she can say “bottle of blue black ink” in French. Stan, comes to her rescue (he happens to be in the neighborhood delivering horsemeat for the Norton’s dog) by saying it in Pig Latin. Jane is immediately taken with Stan, described as having “a nice smile and merry eyes and brown hair with a dip in it” and as “not really tall, but he was tall enough so a medium-size girl could wear heels and not feel she had to scrooch down when she walked beside him.” I’m picturing Bobby Vee here:

Bobby Vee

But! Since it is 1956 Jane has to either come up with a devious way of accidentally-on-purpose running into him, or wait for him to call her on the telephone. Which he does! Now Jane just has to convince her parents to let her go out on a date with him:

“Oh, Mom, do you have to refer to him as ‘this Stanley Crandall?’ Jane thought. It sounded so awful, as if she had picked him up on a street corner someplace.” Jane tries to reassure her parents that “He’s not the type to ride around in a hot rod and throw beer cans out along the highway.”

Mr. and Mrs. Purdy want Jane to date her childhood friend George:

“He’s a nice boy with real interests. He may not seem very exciting to you now, but he is a kind of boy with purpose, the kind of boy who will be a doctor or a scientist when he grows up.”

Yeah, awesome, parents:  nobody wants to date teenage J. Robert Oppenheimer! Especially when he’s an inch shorter than you are so you have to scrooch down when you dance, constantly yammers about his rock collection, has a cowlick, is chaperoned everywhere by both of his parents and (most damningly) “carried his money in a change purse instead of loose in his pockets and took her straight home from the movies.”

Her parents eventually relent, and Jane prepares for her big date by washing her hair (even though she washed it 3 days ago!) and “plucking six hairs out of her left eyebrow and five hairs out of her right”. She however fails to convince her mother to buy her a new dress or hire an interior decorator to make their house less embarrassing. Before sitting down to a hearty dinner of her mother’s onion casserole (GOD! MOM!)

Jane took the bobby pins out of her hair, because her father did not allow her to come to the table with her hair in pin curls…

Yeah, typical 50s father setting arbitrary rules to try and control the women in the family…

…He said it spoiled his appetite to realize that he had a pinhead for a daughter.

Oh. Wait. He’s supposed to be funny! Actually, both of the parents are pretty hilarious, from her mother’s constant hysteria over the thought that Bobby Vee is going to morph into Vic Morrow and take her daughter to a knife fight right out of The Blackboard Jungle, to her father’s excessive doting on the family cat (at one point in the book her father gets up in the middle of the night to shine a flashlight out the bedroom window and congratulate the cat on his skill at killing gophers).

After sitting through introductions with her parents, during which Jane dies of embarrassment at least 500 times, she and Stan are finally off to a movie, stopping off at Nibley’s Confectionary and Soda Fountain (great name for a restaurant! Take note, Love Comes to Anne!) where Jane runs into cashmere sweater queen Marcy, who ruins the thrill of being the first girl to be seen in public with the new boy in town by ordering black coffee when Jane has ordered vanilla ice cream, which she THOUGHT was more sophisticated than her usual chocolate coke. Yeah. Even I can’t keep the hierarchy of soda fountain choices straight. When I go back to 1956 in my fabric-based time machine, I’ll probably accidentally order the wrong thing and get branded a Communist. However, in the end, Jane has to admit that “she had a good time in a miserable sort of way”.

So successful is Jane in convincing her parents that Stan isn’t setting the stage for invading the town with his motorcycle gang or going to take her to a reefer party in the Mission District, she is allowed to go on a group date to a Chinese restaurant in San Francisco with her best friend Julie; Buzz, with whom Jane shares a murky past over an incident involving a stuffed onion in a 6th grade home ec class; and Marcy and her flavor-of-the-month, Greg.

Things Do Not Go Well.

Despite Jane and Julie’s best-laid plans (“It did not take more than an hour on the telephone for the girls to decide they would not wear hats, because if they both went bareheaded it wouldn’t matter what Marcy did about a hat”) the authentic Chinese restaurant that is owned by the parents one of Stan’s old classmates is weird and terrifying: “bowls of strange sauces, platters heaped with crinkled brown objects, mysterious mixtures of unknown foods.” Jane panics:

Now if only she knew which was the won ton, and should she pour the sauce over it or dunk the won ton in the sauce? And what on earth could those floating things be that looked like little brown hands?

Although she is equally White and Suburban, Marcy does not have these problems and hijacks Stan’s attention for the evening. All is lost! But wait! Stan makes it up to Jane by apologizing for Chinese food being so Chinese and buying her a hamburger on the way home. By the time school starts the whole school knows that they are practically going steady!

However! Stan has oddly not asked Jane to the first school dance of the year. As the days go by she hints and finally throws out all decorum and asks him if he is going to ask her. He says he can’t because he already has a date. Jane does what any sensible 15 year old girl would do and freaks the hell out and completely avoids Stan, making Julie store her books in her locker for her, avoiding Nibley’s after school, and throwing herself into her babysitting and reading Julius Caesar, determined to forget Stan and become a top student so that “when she finished high school she would have a selection of scholarships to choose from, she would go to one of those Eastern women’s colleges…” she starts hanging around with Liz, who is on the staff of the school literary magazine and “writes poems with titles like ‘Life and Death: a Dialogue’”.  She considers her employment options as a swingin’ single gal and decides on a career as

an airline stewardess , or a writer of advertising copy for a big department store or perhaps a job at the American embassy in Paris- something like the girls in the pages of Mademoiselle, who always managed to be clever about clothes and to be seen in interesting places with men who had crew cuts.

Oh, Jane you are a girl after my own heart!

Things go from bad to worse when Julie calls the morning after the dance to report that Stan’s date had been a sophisticated 5 foot tall city girl named Bitsy with “one of those sleek new haircuts” and a dress with a straight skirt, and whom everyone agrees is “perfectly darling”. Dang it, once again I was born too late to be a femme fatale on the solely on the basis of my height. Or lack thereof.

Thankfully, before Jane can sit down to compose another Hokku about her feelings (which is like a Haiku, but in 1956),  Stan shows up on her doorstep, looking rather pale and exasperated and explains that he had promised to take Bitsy to the first dance of the year before he moved from San Francisco, even though he would have rather taken Jane, but he is a gentleman of his word, plus his parents made him. He apologizes for not explaining to Jane and generally acting like a huge dorkus for the entire week. He also explains that he had borrowed his parents car to take Bitsy to the dance because he wanted Jane to be the first girl to ride in his new car! Hear that ladies? Stan likes her where it really counts!

Hepped up on the joy of riding in a convertible Ford Model A with a boy, Jane starts feeling quite Marcy-like, and when they stop to show off Stan’s automotive riches to Buzz and Julie, Jane kisses Buzz on a dare. Stan is not pleased. Jane again dies of embarrassment and dorkitude 500 times as Stan drives her to her babysitting job and then drives off, looking quite pained.

Jane agonizes over Stan for four telephone call-less days until at last Julie calls with the wonderful news that Stan is in the hospital! Apparently that pained look wasn’t about Jane kissing Buzz, it was about the fact that his appendix was about to explode. Despite the fact that “she had never known a girl who liked a boy who had his appendix out, and so she had no precedent to follow” Jane decides to send flowers to Stan and goes to the local florist for advice on selecting “masculine flowers”. The florist shamelessly upsells her a monstrous arrangement of Gladiolas, which he then refuses to deliver to the hospital and “for a frantic moment Jane considered rushing out of the shop, never to return”. Yes, I have also been there! Jane eventually gets up her resolve to walk the arrangement to the hospital herself, even though the route takes her right past Nibley’s at soda drinkin’ time, and of course everyone in school is there. But! Jane handles herself with coolness and a sense of humor, and even has a snappy comeback for Marcy’s snotty remarks. Liz-the-intellectual thinks she’s cool and she even attracts the notice of “a boy in a second-year letterman’s sweater”.

When Stan finally returns to school he asks Jane to an outdoor movie fundraiser for the Junior class, where, during the screening of an educational film about John Quincy Adams, he gives Jane his ID bracelet and explains that 16 year old boys are also constantly dying of embarrassment every minute of the day. Yay!

Thus concludes our entirely age-appropriate YA Romance.

Taken Out of Context Department: “A girl shouldn’t hold a baked stuffed onion against a boy forever!”

Haircut Department: Am I the only one who notices that “Buzz” seems to have gone out of fashion as a nickname around the Kennedy assassination?

Sign it Was Written in 1956 Department: “Jane was knitting Stan a pair of Argyle socks for Christmas.”

This entry was posted in Vintage YA Fiction and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

54 Responses to Fifteen By Beverly Cleary

  1. lospeep says:

    Purely a pleasure to read, and I can murkily confirm that a great many 16 year old boys are indeed constantly dying of embarrassment every minute of the day.

  2. Pingback: Seventeenth Summer By Maureen Daly | Lost Classics of Teen Lit, 1939-1989

  3. Madmad says:

    I, for one, want to know what the “tiny brown hands” actually were.

  4. Pingback: Building Your Paperless Library: Digital YA Classics | Lost Classics of Teen Lit, 1939-1989

  5. Thank you for another snerk worthy post and a good morning laugh. This is still one of my all time favorite comfort reads, although I pitch it to my students now as “historical fiction” about what the world was like when their grandparents were young. Since they’re republishing Betty Cornell’s etiquette guide, who knows what upswing there may be in fiction of this era!

    • mondomolly says:

      I agree so much! One of those books where maybe not much “happens”, but is still a compelling read- and certainly the awkwardness of being a teenager hasn’t changed all that much since the 1950s. So glad to hear that it is still being recommended! 🙂

  6. Darshana says:

    I totally remember reading this book when I was in high school, and being astonished. Were teenagers really this innocent during the 1950s? Those two kids “go out” for months and never even kiss!

    • mondomolly says:

      Were the “good old days” ever so innocent? Although I definitely related to Jane and Stan’s constantly lurking fear of being TOTALLY EMBARRASSED. Thanks for your comment!

  7. Pingback: Truth And Consequences By Miriam Young | Lost Classics of Teen Lit, 1939-1989

  8. Emily says:

    Just re read this review and I have to say Fifteen was one of my favorite teen retro novels- I was a teen in the 60s and things were already quite different by then, although I almost wished they weren’t! I read it again in library school in the 70s and had forgotten how truly funny it was. And the original line drawings by Joe and Beth Krush (The Borrowers) were memorable. I have a suggestion for you- Sparrow Lake, by Carol Beach York, from the 60s. Have you ever read it?

    • mondomolly says:

      Thanks for your comment! I too love this book and am so happy to see that others enjoy it as much as I do- I think a lot of the emotions are truly timeless!

      I will check out Sparrow Lake, I haven’t read it, although I have read a few other of York’s books. Thanks for the suggestion!

      • Anonymous says:

        I hope you enjoy it if you find a copy (I ILL’ed mine.). It is the good girl meets bad boy theme- sort of moody and internalized. I had forgotten the title and finally figured it out and re-read it. It left an impression on me in the 60’s when I first read it and I could understand why, all these many years later, when I read it again.

  9. Pingback: The Day The Senior Class Got Married By Gloria D. Miklowitz | Lost Classics of Teen Lit, 1939-1989

  10. Pingback: The Luckiest Girl By Beverly Cleary | Lost Classics of Teen Lit, 1939-1989

  11. jujubees2bee says:

    I had been TRYING and TRYING to find this book as I read it in the 1980’s. I fell in love with it! I finally did a search with “Teen romance in 1980’s with cashmere sweater!” LOL I clicked on “images” and found it and your review! I loved this book – and now, as a 40 something adult, I’m going to get it for MY daughter! BTW – the first kiss in the book? That is what I remember a LONG time ago – the hesitancy and “newness.” She captured it perfectly!

    • mondomolly says:

      Aww, glad you were able to find it! It holds up so well and I’m sure your daughter will be able to relate to the emotions 60 years later (if not the overwhelming need for a yellow rain slicker 😉 )

      Thanks for commenting!

  12. My absolute favorite Beverly Cleary YA teen romance is “Jean and Johnny” (1959) I hope you’ll do that one next. I personally own three copies including the original perma-bound red hardback library discard I picked up at a library book sale with the Joe and Beth Krush illustration on the cover. Shelly Latham eat your heart out!

    • mondomolly says:

      It’s hard to pick a favorite, but it might be a tie between Fifteen and Jean & Johnny for me! I’m sure that I’ll review it here soon!

      Aren’t those Krush covers the best? Thanks for commenting!

  13. Carla says:

    Oh, I loved this book when I first read it at around age 12 or 13. Isn’t this the one that said she ‘never knew a boy’s lips could be so soft’? Awww

  14. Pingback: Jean and Johnny By Beverly Cleary | Lost Classics of Teen Lit, 1939-1989

  15. ninyabruja says:

    The Krushes also illustrated the Betsy-Tacy high school books.

    I think that the true message of the book is not that Stan wants to go steady with Jane, but that she’s learned to be herself.

    • mondomolly says:

      I also like how at the end it is revealed that Stan has been just as embarrassed and unsure about himself at times as Jane had been!

    • The Krushes really shone when they illustrated the turn of the last century, as in the Borrowers series, and the Gone-Away books by Elizabeth Enright. All those ruffles and curlicues and doodads!

  16. ninyabruja says:

    I think that The Pinto Stallion Revolts Again is a snark at Walter Farley (The Black and Island Stallion books) and am curious to know if he and Cleary had an irl clash.

  17. Pingback: Sister of the Bride By Beverly Cleary | Lost Classics of Teen Lit, 1939-1989

  18. Tamaraz says:

    Can I just say I absolutely LOVE Cleary and LOVE Fifteen…I always feel that underneath the “twee” – underneath the 1950s sweetness…..Cleary has an “edge”….I think Ill be reading this book for the rest of my life! 🙂

  19. Audrey says:

    This book is an old favourite of mine – A family friend gave it to me when I was a young teenager in the mid 70s and although it was old fashioned, I noted with envy that my chance of a date with a boy with a car, or even hangin’ with the crowd on my way home from school was pretty remote. Enjoyed the humour of your review. I always liked mom too, who dared to bare her legs despite being ‘practically 40’. And poor old Julie who wears a girdle for her Chinese restaurant extravaganza. AND has forgive her best mate for kissing her boyfriend while she’s stood righ there. Now that’s pretty shocking, even now…

  20. Anonymous says:

    I am 72 years old, and have been an avid reader since 3rd grade. One of the few books I remember reading in my early life is Fifteen. It was pretty fresh when I read it, and I must tell you that it was very accurate. Girls did not think about sex, but they thought a lot about romance. The culture was so protective of those feelings! I read my old diaries, and they read like Fifteen. I was pretty single minded at 15: I thought about boys all the time. However, I was able to remain virginal until I married. The reason? Before the sexual revolution of the late sixties, our culture gave teens the freedom to like each other, and date each other, and even “go steady”, without assuming that sex would be involved. I never felt stifled or deprived; It was a great way to grow up, it was healthier for individuals and families…..and I miss those days.

  21. mondomolly says:

    Reblogged this on Lost Classics of Teen Lit: 1939-1989 and commented:

    The literary world lost a colossus this week, when Beverly Cleary died just a few weeks short of her 105th birthday.

    The author who gave us memorable characters including Everyboy Henry Huggins, the unrepentantly imaginative Ramona Quimby and her sensible older sister Beezus (always slightly insecure that she was being outshone by her younger sibling) (#BeezusesUnite), various Bay Area proto-Hippies, and the legion of loving, flawed, funny and relatable parents.

    We featured a number of Cleary’s early works in this space over the years, and may I suggest we Drop Everything And Read, perhaps starting with her first YA volume, continuously in print since 1956.

  22. Maryn says:

    Oh, how I loved Fifteen, Jean and Johnny, The Luckiest Girl, Sister of the Bride, and wasn’t there one called Sixteen, too? I read all of them during high school in the early 70s and although already 15-20 years old at the time, those books really captured a teenager’s emotions and relationships. My life in a small town wasn’t that different (no Chinese food though!) even though hairstyles and fashions had changed. Beverly Cleary was truly an icon, and those books deserve to be remembered as much as the Ramona and Henry Huggins books to (I loved those, too).

    • mondomolly says:

      Thanks for commenting! I agree, these books are so timeless and Cleary is a literay giant who will be missed!

    • Sandra Leonetti says:

      Cleary never wrote a “Sixteen” or a sequel to Fifteen. There’s a collection of Maureen Daly short stories called “Sixteen and Other Stories”; could that be it?

      • Maryn says:

        The book I’m thinking of was definitely a Cleary; I have read the Maureen Daly stories and in fact my daughter did a Speech piece based on Sixteen. Possibly the book I’m actually remembering is The Luckiest Girl. It wasn’t a sequel to Fifteen or to Jean and Johnny. It’s not such a pressing question that I want to put it in “Name that Book.” But thanks for the suggestion and for the information that Cleary didn’t write a book by that title. I feel better knowing I don’t have to try to hunt it down, LOL!

        • mondomolly says:

          Check out my other reviews for Cleary’s highs chool books, the heroines deffintely share enough DNA that it could be mistaken for a sequel! Thanks for commenting!

  23. Barbara O'Connor Hayes says:

    Funny that you reblogged this review when I was just remembering that the Nortons’ dog’s name was Cuthbert. I guess that’s what happens when you love a book so much that you read it many times—the details get etched in your memory for the rest of your life, which is fine with me.~I just read an excerpt on a website where one teen said Fifteen was an OK book and another called it “forgetable.” Not to me!~Would you consider blogging about YA horse-themed romances from the 1950s or thereabouts? There are a lot of good ones: Scarlet Royal and Spring Comes Riding to name a couple. Thanks for considering!

    • mondomolly says:

      Thanks for commenting! I am always looking for recommendation for books that are in extremely specific subgenres, I’ll add the two you suggest to my list!

  24. Sheryl A says:

    This is one of my favorite YA novels, by one of my very favorite authors!! Love that Beverly Cleary got out of Beezus-and-Ramona-ville, but kept the spirit alive with the babysitting adventures in this book. It’s really innocent, but the parental interactions ARE hilarious and I love all the thoughts running through Jane’s head, like when Stan first calls, and she’s downplaying her thrill (to herself in parentheses)… ‘(Careful Jane, don’t be too eager.)’ And she tries to be like Marcy Stokes, but it doesn’t work out, she’s just not the “cashmere-sweater” type. Perfect high school angst.
    One thing that always bugged me though: her wardrobe. Does she really only have 5 things to wear on a date? She runs through her dresses to decide for the 1st date, but couldn’t wear her yellow cotton dress because Stan already saw her in it, while babysitting… who babysits in a dress? So what the heck does she wear to school? I know it’s the 50s but really?
    And yes, the new cover art is insipid. I have a Scholastic paperback “pocket” edition from 1970 and it actually has a cool cover of a girl in a blue jacket and mini-skirt with a backscratcher at her feet. I bought an e-version of the book (to make sure they didn’t change the great context/writing, I just hate when authors bring books “up to present day” and mess up the atmosphere… I’m talking to you here, Lois Duncan) and the Fifteen e-book came with a stupid ice cream soda cover art. Bleck.

    • Marynn says:

      LOL about the 5 things to wear on a date–but surely you remember high school, when (in your mind at least) following the current trend is paramount, and believing that if you’ve been seen in once certain outfit once, “everyone” has marked that down in their mind and will know you’re repeating? She probably wears skirts and blouses to school, with penny loafers or saddle shoes and bobby socks. Whether she thinks a skirt and blouse (and bobby socks) isn’t dressy enough for a date or whether she thinks Stan will think she hasn’t got any other clothes to wear, I am not sure! Also, when I started babysitting in the late 60s, my parents insisted I wear a skirt rather than pants–I guess the purpose of that was to project a more business-like image. So wearing the yellow cotton dress to a babysitting job never struck me as unusual at all.

      • Sheryl says:

        You’re so right! A totally teenage dilemma – I have nothing to wear. Guess I just wanted Beverly Cleary to include some bits about her “dungarees” (I love that term for jeans). And I do love the descriptions of her “blue princess dress” and “dirndl and peasant blouse”.. now I have to look those clothing references up on Google. Fun!

    • Lizzy says:

      Oh man, those Lois Duncan ebooks are so annoying, it really sucks you can’t get an original version of the text. I don’t want these clunky tech-related updates (which already look dated since those editions are a decade ago)!

    • mondomolly says:

      Thanks for commenting! Some of those 70s paperback cover are really cool, I like the one for Jean and Johnny even though it totally doesn’t match the era of the actual story!

  25. Susan says:

    I’ve always been intrigued by the soda fountain concept. It’s so ubiquitous in books and TV shows of the era. We had some relatives-of-relatives who owned one in the town where my parents grew up. I was about six or seven when I last went there in the mid-60s so I didn’t experience the teen vibe that supposedly existed and whether the portrayals are accurate. Molly, if you ever figure out how to time-travel back to 1956 I want to go to one with you, wearing bobby sox and saddle shoes 😉 ! I always enjoy when I run across an authentic retro one while traveling.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s